Restoration & Ice Cream

restoration and ice cream logo

For 200 years, downtown Grove City has been home to entrepreneurs and their dreams.  Each building has a story of great men and woman who have had ideas and actually had the confidence to make them a reality, with varying success. Even though every business is a gamble, sometimes people come along that seem to have the right combination of passion and a plan. That’s the case with one couple, who are not just starting a new business, but also attempting to save one of Olde Town’s largest and most historic buildings.

Built in 1906, you’ll know 241 South Broad as being the Hallmark store, turned pizza shop, turned hot dog shop. During that same time, you would have also noticed the gradual and very noticeable deterioration.  What you may not know, is that the large 22,000 square foot, three story structure has housed everything from the newly formed Grove City High School, to a bowling alley. Dotty McGill’s Dance studio was also once on the building’s third floor. Today, the building is now in the hands of Dave and Jeanie Mills, and will soon be home to “Sweet Jeanie’s, the happiest place in town”.

Renovations underway at Sweet Jeanie's
Renovations underway at Sweet Jeanie’s
A before picture from Sweet Jeanie's
A before picture from Sweet Jeanie’s

The focus, especially at first, will be homemade ice cream, but a diner-style menu will soon follow. The couple have spent the last few months shopping around for unique pieces to fill the space, even driving as far as Indiana to purchase what will be the showpiece of the restaurant, a vintage 1948 soda bar. They’ve also purchased vintage booths and chairs, along with classic refrigerators and other period décor (Also note: they’re looking for 1950’s furniture in the area for a living room set up that they have planned near the entry). The goal, to make it seem like the place has been there for generations, with a few modern twists. “We didn’t seek out the vintage look, but when we found the soda bar, we knew that was the direction we had to go,” said owner, temporary construction worker and ice cream maker Jeanie Mills. She has done much of the work herself. From bringing down layers of walls, to sanding down the original hardwood floors, she has put more than just her dream on the line. At this time last year she was a nurse in Pittsburgh. Her husband David is the Olde Town manager, and the two knew that they wanted to start a homemade ice cream business in Olde Town. Now recently “retired,” and living just outside of Grove City, Jeanie spends most of her days putting sweat equity into the future restaurant. It has been a family affair, with David’s 85 year old parents also helping rip up nails and clear out the garbage. The bright colored walls, linoleum tiles and a drop-down ceiling have been removed to expose century old brick walls, original hardwood floors, and an ornate tin ceiling. With work still to be done, the before and after is already jaw-dropping.

1948 Soda Fountain purchased for Sweet Jeanie's (picture taken in Indiana where it was purchased)
1948 Soda Fountain purchased for Sweet Jeanie’s (picture taken in Indiana where it was purchased)
241 S. Broad St. in Olde Town. The right storefront will soon be Sweet Jeanie's
The right storefront at 241 S. Broad St will soon be Sweet Jeanie’s
Renovation work at Sweet Jeanie's
Part way through renovations at Sweet Jeanie’s

“We want this to be a place that college and high school kids want to hang out, but then also be a place that brings back memories for grandparents,” says Jeanie. “It’s going to be the place that parents let their kids ride bikes to with their allowance money, like the old days.” She plans on having a candy bar, with nickel and dime candies, bringing back a nostalgic part of Broad Street that many in town have missed.

The building will someday be much more than just Sweet Jeanie’s. They plan on restoring the entire structure, which they hope to be the center of activity in Olde Town. The plan includes renting out another street level storefront, which thankfully has many of the same historic characteristics, and needs a lot less work. The basement, which was once a bowling alley (the paint job proves it), and more recently the Jam House (youth center), David plans on restoring it back into a performing space. A large bar, built in tables, and a small stage still stand in the basement. Jeanie’s dream is for it to have a “Speak Easy” feel to it, creating a unique concert venue for downtown.

Painted walls of the former bowling alley.
Small stage inside the basement of 241 South Broad Street, formerly the Jam House Youth Center
Seating and bar area in the basement.

They also have big plans for the second and third floors. The second floor apartments will someday be completely redone. As for the expansive third floor, they look to turn it into a large events venue. It was the third floor that you can tell once housed part of the high school and Dotty McGill’s Dance Studio. A large entry way, along with two massive rooms make it very reminiscent of the Corinthian Banquet Hall in Sharon. An elevator would someday be added.

The exterior will also see improvements with new windows and a restored entry way. While the entire building’s restoration is roughly a five year plan for the Mills, the space Sweet Jeanie’s will occupy will be temporarily open for the Wine Walk this Saturday, February 28th, and the grand opening (construction permitting) is tentatively planned for the first full day of spring, and Jeanie’s birthday, March 21st. Less than a month away, that gives Grove City one more reason to celebrate the end of winter.

*UPDATE: Sweet Jeanie’s Grand Opening has been delayed to April 18,2015

*Tickets for the Winter Wine Walk on Saturday, February 28 from noon to 6pm are sold at b’gifted at 216 S. Broad St. and online at

by Alex DeGroff

Jeanie and David Mills
Jeanie hard at work.
Jeanie hard at work.
241 South Broad Street in 2011
Neglected 241 South Broad Street in 2011

16 thoughts on “Restoration & Ice Cream

    1. I think that will go well in Grove City! The latest thing that was in the basement of that building was “Church at the Crossroads!” It was there for a few years. It has been gone for about 2 1/2 years now. The church did quite a bit of work to the basement. It was in bad shape when the church went into that building! It has potential!


    2. When I think ice cream… it always reminds me of Steese’s Ice Cream that was located on blacktown road. The original owners grandson is still in the area and making ice cream in his basement. He has the original recipe.. don’t know if he would share with you or not but Steese’s Ice Cream was the best ice cream ever. The grandson’s name is Jimmy Richardson, son of Ginny Steese Richardson. Having their recipe would bring back a lot of Grove City History too


  1. How exciting. Love that soda fountain look.
    I took dance lessons as a kid at the Dotty McGill studio on the 3rd floor.
    Each time I visit Grove City, I see good changes.


  2. Thank you, Dave and Jeanie, for working to make our town beautiful. By the way, ICE CREAM is my favorite food, so I have already told my husband I will be a regular customer!


  3. About a month ago, I was downtown GC, and commented to my family that the old Hallmark shop always made me sad to see it in such disrepair. It was such a sweet shop for a time. This ice cream shop sounds nifty!


  4. Great to hear of your efforts. Will come visit the shop next time I get to Grove City. I live in CA now, but try to get back now and then to see family and friends.


  5. Excited to see new life breathed into that grand old place, and new business to our community. Can’t wait to see how it comes along!


  6. What a nice addition to downtown Grove City. I wish you lots of Success and the next time I’m in GC I’ll be sure to stop in for some ice cream.


  7. That building also housed Sloan’s Hardware, a Sears catalog store, the Ski Shack and GC bikes. The floors were redone and walls and ceiling exposed for the ski shop but have been covered for years. It is so refreshing to see the beauty of the building exposed again. Good luck; we will be sure to frequent your business.


  8. How great is this my daughter is going to be apart of this and i know this is going to be a great place to have fun with family and friends.
    Way to go my the dreams begin good luck on this new beginning


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s